Industry Collaboration – Poll

0

A more collaborative relationship between regulators and life insurance industry stakeholders would better serve the aspirations of the financial advice profession for the ultimate benefit of the consumer.

Our latest poll stems from the outcome of the UK regulator’s recently-released report into the operations of the pure protection market – out of which its principal concern was not that risk commissions should be curbed but rather that too many UK consumers do not hold life insurance cover.

In what was described by former Zurich exec and AFA CEO, Philip Kewin as “…a useful case study in collaborative regulation”, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority has proposed a package of regulator, industry and stakeholder-led measures to improve awareness, access and the sales process, by using existing regulatory frameworks. He says the FCA is now engaging with industry to develop and implement those measures (see: UK Commissions Remain Uncapped – What Can Australia Learn?).

good regulation …should also ask whether the regulatory response itself risks reducing access, innovation and competition

Comparing the contrasting approaches taken by the Australian and UK regulators in this area, Kewin says good regulation should certainly challenge poor consumer outcomes, but “…it should also ask whether the regulatory response itself risks reducing access, innovation and competition.”

He says The FCA’s protection market study demonstrates there is another way: “…investigate first, listen to the market, test the evidence, identify the specific problem—and then work collaboratively with industry to fix it.” He says this is not weaker regulation but may simply be better regulation.

Riskinfo notes that in Australia, ASIC, does not make the rules. Its role is to oversee and enforce the rules and regulations decreed by the law-makers. But in its enforcement activities, should the regulator – together with the broad cross-section of industry interests which exist – be taking a more collaborative approach for the betterment of all stakeholders and for the ultimate benefit of the consumer?

Tell us what you think and we’ll continue the conversation next week…